Nathan Smith vs Ed James

Nathan Smith leads on 6 of 12 metrics to Ed James's 5. Nathan Smith is clearest ahead for tackles, ball security (possession lost) and duel win rate; Ed James is clearest ahead for final-third passes, expected goals (xG) and ball recoveries. Both compared with centre-backs in lower leagues.

Nathan Smith averages 1.14 tackles per 90 on current form, ahead of Ed James on 0.52.

Every stat is per 90 minutes or a rate from club matches. Form weights recent matches most heavily; Season uses only this club season. The player with the higher number wins each metric, except ball security where fewer losses is better. Percentiles show where each player sits against others in his own role and level.